A whale of a tale
Monday, May 14th, 2007
My Clean Break feature this week is a story about a Toronto company called WhalePower Corp. that has designed a new type of wind-turbine blade that dramatically improves turbine efficiency. What’s unique about the design is that it mimics the aerodynamic feature of a humpback whale’s flipper, which has bumps or “tubercles” along its leading edge. Scientists have found that the tubercles reduce the drag and increase the lift on the flipper, having the effect of delaying stall. Earlier studies have attempted to apply this principle to airplane wings and rudders on boats, but WhalePower is adapting it to blades for wind turbines, fans — essentially anything with a rotating blade that moves through air or fluid. The co-founders of WhalePower claim their blade captures more of the wind’s energy at lower speeds where conventional turbines tend to stall. For example, a turbine equipped with WhalePower blades could produce the same amount of electricity from 5 metre-per-second winds as a conventional turbine tends to produce with winds blowing at 8 metres per second. This means the humpback-designed turbines could allow wind farms to produce more kilowatt-hours a year, improving the business case for wind farms.
The big question is: Even if this is a superior blade design, would the industry be willing to change? Given turbine manufacturers are already having a tough time keeping up with demand, there’s not much incentive in radically changing the design of their product for the benefit of customers. And while WhalePower says it has a way to retrofit existing turbine blades, there’s the question of voiding the warranty — something most wind-farm operators are reluctant to do.
All that said, it’s a neat company that’s bound to attract further attention from investors and the media. And the approach could represent a way for a newcomer to the wind-turbine manufacturing market to distinguish itself from the competitive pack.


Tyler Hamilton is senior energy reporter and columnist for the Toronto Star, Canada's largest daily newspaper. In addition to this Clean Break blog, Tyler writes a weekly column of the same name that discusses trends, happenings and innovators in the cleantech market. This blog is a personal project started in April 2005. It is not an official blog of the newspaper.